Bottom: Diaper Genie. Your support helps me run this blog thank you! The Ubbi Diaper Pail is slightly smaller than the Diaper Genie which is a good 5 inches taller. Now, lets look at one of the best diaper pails and Genie alternatives out there: the Munchkin Step pail. This hasn't been a big deal for me. Note that once you confirm, this action cannot be undone. And It holds quite a few days of diapers before you have to roll out more of the bag. Main reason for buying this was we will save long term as no speciality bags needed. The Munchkin Step Pail has managed to do great in various roundups conducted by reviewers from highly trusted sources that . Baking soda provides safe, effective and natural odor elimination. Use of this site is subject to our terms of use and privacy policy. With the long list of baby gadgets, clothes and accessories you need to buy, you might be wondering if you need a diaper pail. Can you use grocery bags in your pail? Sorry, but I see these odor-absorbing filters as more of a drawback than an advantage. However, it is more expensive, both up front and in the long-run, because you will probably have to buy the name-brand refill rings. I have yet to have issues with it months later. The steel diaper pail can hold up to 55 dirty diapers. (For every diaper pail sold, Munchkin will plant a tree. Offers Superior odor protection Made with 7-layer odor-barrier film Each diaper ring holds up to 272 newborn diapers Fits ALL Diaper Genie Elite, Complete, Elite, Essentials and "Mini" Pails. Other than the fact that at Babies R Us (at least) the genie is cheaper? Munchkin one works great in concealing odor. A great diaper pail will also have one-handed (or one-footed!) Footprint: 21.2 x 12.3 x 11.1 inches. Group Leaders communicate with staff moderators and escalate potential violations for review, but they dont moderate discussions. While the tall build of the Munchkin Step means you dont have to bend far, pushing the diaper through the lid might put some strain on a new moms back! . TJ is the Executive Editor of Reviewed.com. The good news is, Munchkin refills work with Diaper Genie! Munchkin Step Diaper Pail A lot of parents already trust the Munchkin brand, so the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is another clear option as an alternative to the Diaper Genie. However, the difference is small, and as you can expect to get several years of use out of both options, we think the Munchkin Step price is fair. With my method, it took me a long time to fill up a diaper pail and those diaper contents that were in there had a chance to, well, percolate. One of the top reasons to choose one pail over the other is often its ability to mask the odor. Never had used a diaper pail with my toddler (would put them in disposable diaper bags) but when I became pregnant this time, I could not stand the smell of diapers (made me sick) so I got the munchkin one. The Diaper Genie Complete is a sleek-looking, plastic diaper pail. We'll be in touch soon. >> Munchkin vs. If you still think its going to squish against the entrance to the pail, wrap it in another mini trash bag (like a pet bag) before putting it in the diaper pail. We respect everyones right to express their thoughts and opinions as long as they remain respectful of other community members, and meet What to Expects Terms of Use. Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed's editors. Wishlist . think twice before sharing personal details, foster a friendly and supportive environment, remove fake accounts, spam and misinformation, delete posts that violate our community guidelines, reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts. Now, I asked my sis (a busy mom with 2 under 2) about her diaper routine. Bags are annoying and it was still smelly. Munchkin pail here - my baby is 4 months old and there's been no smell or issues with the pail. For Step & Pail, purchase the 1pk Arm and Hammer Puck Baking Soda Cartridge. The Munchkin Step Pail is one of the very best Diaper Pails that one can get for around $60. A Group Leader is a What to Expect community member who has been selected by our staff to help maintain a positive, supportive tone within a group. Required fields are marked *. 20% 32 votes Report Reply to Post Re: Ubbi Pail vs. The Ubbi also looks great, with a steel frame, low-profile hinge, and a variety of attractive color options. From time to time, it will be necessary to give the pail a good clean with an antibacterial spray. If you dont like smell or having to squish diapers into a pail, stay away from munchkin. The Munchkin Step pail is tall and has an out of reach button for little fingers, but neither of these pails have a child lock. The Munchkin Step is a foot pedal operated diaper pail with a clever twist and seal method used to keep odors in. All rights reserved. No experience with munchkin though. And then, the smell is just out there, stinking up your nursery. Alternatively, you can also use ordinary plastic shopping bags in both pails. Its a little more money upfront, but we highly recommend jumping up to the Diaper Genie Complete. They also have a trap door in the front for easy diaper disposal. This is used to absorb odors and also releases a nice, lavender scent. This deodorizer works well, but it does need to be replaced roughly every 30 days. Tell us a bit more about you so we can get to know each other better. It is easy to use with is foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening. If the diaper genie smells are simply too bad for one diaper pail deodorizer idea to work, try multiple methods. But with heavily soiled, squishy diapers, you're going to have to shove them into the bag. Note : Not for use with Munchkin Step and Pail Diaper Pails. when i. Arm & Hammer cd92007 member January 2014 If you have a diaper pail that is lined with a standard trash bag, its a no-brainer. Many parents will attest to the high quality performance of both the Munchkin Step and the Diaper Genie. Email us and we'll compare notes. The only diaper pail compatible with both Refill Rings and Snap, Seal & Toss Bags. Read on for the Munchkin Step vs Diaper Genie Complete guide to the differences between the two. Munchkin features a Patented self-sealing system that has made this pail the top choice for odor control. The Diaper Genie Complete had the strongest pail features of any that we tried, and it comes with a reasonable price tag. Its not noticeable with a newborn or just 1 to 2 diapers, but when the bag is nearly full its impossible to escape. Munchkin Step - Main Differences Capacity Closure Anti-microbial Odor-Absorbing Disks & Filters Special Bags Refill Rings Ease Of Use Safety Blade Material Cost Munchkin Step Review Munchkin Arm & Hammer Disks Odor Control Refill Bags Inserting Diapers Expense Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Review Opening The Lid Carbon Filters Refill Bags . The biggest issue is the odor locking control mechanism, which is basically one big plastic arm that seals the bag shut. Does your favorite option require special bags? Has arguably the best diaper disposal of any testedat least in terms of cleanliness and odor control. In this Diaper Genie vs Munchkin Step review, we have compared both diaper pails compare, focusing on usability, odor prevention, price, and more so you can find the perfect diaper pail for you and your little one! at the best online prices at eBay! Open a window or the front door on nice days to let fresh air into the house. We strive to provide you with a high quality community experience. Read More. Great for diaper bags, diaper pails, changing tables, hampers and more. We prefer it over the Munchkin Step as you can easily dispose of diapers. Im reading reviews but so confused. I know the pushing part is part of the mixed review but idk maybe cause I always try to wrap my wipes in the diaper, I dont have poop everywhere on the diaper so its not rubbing all over the bag as you push it in also people claim it doesnt close properly but I think they arent inserting the bag refill canister properly. It is a step-to-open design requiring only one hand for diaper deposits. Purchases made through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission. Looking at all the features together, which brand does the better job controlling odor? In my case, its not very frequent because I use cloth diapers during the day. It is difficult to find off-brand bags that fit the Munchkin Step pail, so beware of liner bags that claim they fit the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail! While the foot pedal makes for hands-free, easy access for parents, it can also pose a danger for little ones. Others have foot pedals that allow you to do the work yourself. Besides, steel is much nicer to look at. Heres my comprehensive comparison between the two! When you open it you do have to push the diaper in because as you close it retracts and closes as its way to help conceal odor(thats the only time you get whiff of the smell) but as soon as you close the lid smell is gone. Using the ubbi this time around. Double-lock diaper pail design. Off-brand rings fit just fine. They are expensive and disgusting to change and clean. The Diaper Genie is so popular that the name diaper genie has become synonymous with all diaper pails. Group Black's collective includes Essence, The Shade Room and Naturally Curly. I have gone back and forth for many weeks and spent hours comparing the diaper genie to the munchkin diaper pails. This means that I used cloth diapers during the day and disposable diapers overnight. But I dont buy the armor hammer deodorizer because they get expensive. Munchkin VS diaper genie VS ubbi. The Diaper Genie Expressions was not one of our favorite diaper pails. Do Munchkin refills work with Diaper Genie. As the bag fills up you also have to put more force onto the plastic door to get the diaper through. The Diaper Genie is a cheaper system overall than the Munchkin Step. Another video for you guys! In this case, you can use regular garbage bags and dont fret over odor containment, because youre removing the smelly mess every day (or more frequently). Group Black's collective includes Essence, The Shade Room and Naturally Curly. They still smell. Latest: May 2017 Babies. And if you like this guide on Diaper Genie vs Munchkin Step, then youll love our other diapering guides on Huggies Snug And Dry vs Little Movers, how long can I leave a wet diaper on, Hello Bello vs Pampers, and best diapers to prevent blowouts. My sister was plowing through disposables when she had a newborn baby and an 14-month old, and needed to empty her Diaper Genie every 3 days. The Diaper Genie measures 9.38 x 12.06 x 27 inches compared to the Ubbi Diaper Pail which is 12.5 x 8.75 x 21.6 inches in size. You're all set to get the latest from Reviewed. Click to reveal it operates with an easy-to-use step pedal. Buy at Amazon Ideally, you want to place your pail as close to your changing table or changing pad on your dresser as possible. Both pails have a built-in blade to cut off the liners at any length. The branded bags are expensive, and over time, this cost can really add up. Like PP, I'm looking into the Ubbi this time. Use these Nursery Fresh Diaper Pail Refills for superior odor protection. If it doesnt drop down right away, just use the step lever a few times to make the diaper fall down. Playtex Refill Bags, Ideal for Diaper Genie Diaper Pails, 270 Count 3 Packs.. 7445025696686 | eBay Heres how Diaper Genie and Munchkin Pail compare in terms of their features. Arm & Hammer Snap, Seal & Toss Diaper Pail Bag Refills, 6pk. Our top picks are the two most expensive models, with Munchkin - STEP at around $56 and Ubbi at about $80. Its easy to see that the Genie requires more carbon filter replacements over the course of a year. Childproof lock. If youre open to other suggestions, Ive used a dekor for the last 2 years & love it. munchkin vs diaper genie coming in a variety of types but also different price range. Hey,FTM and wondering if anyone has had any experience of one or both of the diaper genie complete or munchkin step diaper pails?Any recommendations welcome, thanks . Still, others have a simple hole that lets diapers fall to the bottom on their own. This is to be expected, but if you have a very, very full diaper, you might have a bit of worry about squishing a diaper through the opening and possibly getting a bit off a mess on yourself. It's pricey, but I heard it's WELL worth it, and it will even out in price over the long run because you're not buying specialty bags. Still, the pail does a good job containing the smell otherwise. Your trust is really important to me: This article includes affiliate links to products that I think are useful for our readers. These refill bags are the best option for the Munchkin pail systems, proving to be durable and containing odor flawlessly. But, I like to try things out & form my own opinion. What to Expect supports Group Black and its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. I loved my diaper genie, it was even a hand me down. And it can use any type of bag. The Munchkin mechanism also twists the bag to prevent odors from escaping. But best of all, theComplete Pail features Double Air-Tite clamps that work with the 7-layer diaper refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double odor protection. Unlike the Diaper Genie, which creates a small antechamber for the dirty diaper to sit in, the Munchkin Step twists the top of the bag to create a mini seal when you close the lid. In some, the liners were tough to change; in others, they required you to shove squishy, messy diapers through a trapdoor, or they simply don't absorb odor and stunk up the joint. The puck deodorizer can be refilled with standard baking soda. Of course, this depends on the size of the diapers and whether you use cloth diapers or disposable diapers. When the top is sealed, the air will not smell bad and you wont even notice you have a collection of dirty diapers in a pail. Playtex did add the option to buy sleeves with geometric prints that make the pail look prettier, but that does little to justify the other drawbacks here. I found that I have to use this pail together with an air purifier to avoid my nursery smelling of baby poop. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin work best with their own branded liners, but the initial cost of the Diaper Genie is typically less. You shouldnt have any major problems using either diaper pail, as theyre both intuitively designed. It comes in four colors pink, grey, while and blue. However, Ive never had trouble cramming a diaper through the opening. H0w often you need to empty your diaper pail depends on how many diapers you have in there which depends on the age of your kids, and how many kids you have. Are there more budget-friendly choices to consider? Getting diapers through the opening requires some pushing. The Diaper Genie Complete also includes the best odor fighter we tested. After that, rinse both the inside and outside of your diaper pail. Munchkin. The Arm & Hammer branded option releases a pleasant lavender smell, and lasts for roughly 90 days. What is better: Diaper Genie or Munchkin? When youre preparing for your little one, your to buy list might be considerably longer. Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Bag Refills, 72 Count Arm and Hammer bag refills make diaper disposal easy wherever you are . Just open the lid and remove. The Diaper Genie Complete is the best diaper pail we tested. This educational content is not medical or diagnostic advice. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I've had the diaper genie for 2 years with my son and never have really been happy with it. By Sharon Feiereisen. I'm an experience mom of two, wife, writer, editor, and passionate parenting advocate! You can find off-brand refills for the Diaper Genie, but it is much harder to find off-brand bags that work with the Munchkin pail. Consult your doctor/pediatrician in case of any doubts. The Munchkin Step diaper pail has a lot going for it: It works with both single bags and Diaper Genie-style ring refills, the pail does a good job of containing ambient stink when closedthanks to. The Diaper Genie Complete is an airtight portable pail specially designed to contain the odor of dirty diapers. The foot pedal opening mechanism is easy to use. Its foul. Note that once you confirm, this action cannot be undone. Best Customizable Diaper Pail Playtex Diaper Genie Expressions. While its initially more expensive than the Diaper Genie Complete, the design of this diaper pail will save you money in the long term because it uses regular trash bags instead of proprietary liner bagsmaking it our pick for Best Value: With trash bags costing about 10 cents per bag, you'll save upwards of $200 (or more) over the life of the pail. You have to contain that stuff. Generally, Munchkin is more budget-friendly and has been proven to be the No.1 option for odor control. The Diaper Gene releases a bad smell into the air when you open it to drop in a new diaper, the Munchkin only allows a tiny bit of stink to escape. Here are some things to consider. Before we start our reviews, let's get something straight. Diaper Genie vs. She uses only disposable diapers with both of her babies and is a dedicated diaper pail user. Diaper Genie vs. Amazon Associates Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.Home | About | Contact | Privacy Policy. While both pails are popular options, Ive found that the Munchkin has a few advantages that make it my personal favorite. They are inexpensive, and bulk buying can reduce the cost even further, but it is something extra for busy moms to think about. Using trash bags certainly simplifies things in a pinch but, many times, they dont contain smells quite as well. When you lift the lid to put a new diaper in, you may get a little stinky sniff, but its not a big waft and goes away when the lid is down. Despite the rubber seals around the rim and lid, it just isn't that great at containing smells. . Let's get one thing out of the way: a garbage pail designed specifically for diapers is a must from day 1 . Its a little more money upfront, but we highly recommend jumping up to the Complete. Bonus: For every pail purchased, Munchkin will plant a tree. Coming in first is a diaper pail you are probably familiar with and have seen at countless baby showers. I just put a regular refresher and stick it in the pale. The educational health content on What To Expect is reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts to be up-to-date and in line with the latest evidence-based medical information and accepted health guidelines, including the medically reviewed What to Expect books by Heidi Murkoff. I even bag mine with those diaper sacks and it still stinks when I open it, but if I dont you can smell it a mile away even when its closed. I have gone back and forth for many weeks and spent hours comparing the diaper genie to the munchkin diaper pails. I have the munchkin for my 2 year old (had since birth) I love it. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We're in the process of buying a new diaper pail. Just drop the diaper in, close the lid, and the diaper is released into the bag. Dkor - Plus is around $40 and Baby Trend - Diaper Champ Deluxe is around $30. After looking into the most popular pails on the market, we think the best diaper pail and diaper genie on the market is the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete (available at Amazon for $49.97) . Youve got a whole lot of poopy diapers right where your kiddo sleeps. check out Munchkin deodorizers & refills here, ranking of the best Diaper Genie alternatives, Get your Munchkin Step + FREE travel pail here >>, Stokke Steps vs. Tripp Trapp Review & Comparison of Stokke High Chairs. But, once you open the lid, the two flaps or clamps move aside, unlock the seal and release a pungent odor of poopy diapers. Diaper Genie - Expressions, our pick for best lower-cost diaper pail, costs under $25. 0 Compare . With 7 layers and a lavender scent, these bags are able to keep bad smells away. If youre opting for this solution, layer a few bags to prevent spills from seeping through. Others allow you to use standard trash bags. The way a diaper pail seals determines the level of odor control you can expect. When the lid opens, the first thing you will see has an Arm and Hammer baking soda disk fitted inside of the Munchkin Step. Nothing other than a hermetically sealed chamber or being upwind is going to stop the stink of soiled diapers. Simply pull the front of the pail forward, cut the liner with the built-in blade, and tie the end. You might want to read an article I wrote recently about some Diaper Genie alternatives? Although they are more expensive, the Munchkin bag refills are nice, because they have baking soda for maximum odor control. What I particularly like about the Arm and Hammer disks are that you can easily replace with baking soda from your own kitchen. Step on the foot pedal, allow the lid to lift up and insert the soiled diaper through the gap in the center of the pail. Backed with a Masters Degree in Public Health, a Bachelor of Science in Health Promotion, a long career in health and safety, and 10 years of hands on experience using, researching, and testing baby products, I love to use my parenting experience to support and encourage other parents. Both diaper pails are compact enough to fit into even smaller baby rooms without getting in the way. Pictures of Munchkin Step belong to Munchkin brand. Many diaper pails have a squeegee-style contraption that pushes diapers deep down to the bottom of the barrel. In terms of odor prevention, this system is best, but it has a noticeable downside. Your post will be hidden and deleted by moderators. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Playtex Refill Bags, Ideal for Diaper Genie Diaper Pails, 270 Count 3 Packs.. at the best online prices at eBay!